| “ | What? Afraid someone will steal your Dark Magic thunder? | ” |
— Faye to Cassie, about possibly being John Blackwell's daughter.
| ||
When Faye read her mother's diary, she realized that she and John Blackwell were secretly hooking up around the time she was conceived. That lead her to believe that he was her father. This proved to be incorrected, though when he denied it and Diana was revealed to be the other Blackwell child. However, John did seem to care for Faye and told her that even if her biological father was not there for her, he was.